bird silhouette

William Lane Craig

ANIMAL PAIN

“Schon eine Welt, in der im Prinzip alles so ist wie in unserer, in der aber alle fleischfressenden Tiere ihre jeweilige Beute mit einem Schlag töten, ohne sie vorher unnötig zu quälen, wäre besser als unsere.”

Well, would it? Maybe the world would be better without such activity; but who really knows? Such activity may be connected to some evolutionary advantage for these animals that enables them to flourish. Cats, for example, learn to be more effective hunters through such activity. The orkas’ activity is probably due to their higher intelligence. So Beckermann needs to answer two questions: (1) What is the evolutionary advantage of such behavior? (2) What would be the result of eliminating this evolutionary advantage? Eliminating such activity might eliminate cats and orkas.

So would a world without cats and orkas really be better? Would you like it better if cats and orkas did not exist? Do you think that the world would be a better place if all the cats and orkas went extinct? My goodness, we’ve got two of these animals that live in our house with us (and I don’t mean orkas!). I, at least, am glad they’re part of our ecosystem, even given their predatory activity.

And remember: God may have some non-biological reason for creating such an ecosystem as the arena in which the human drama takes place. Maybe only in such a world will the optimal number of people come freely to salvation.