William Lane Craig
CAUSAL PREMISE
1. “Erstens, folge aus der Annahme, dieses Prinzip sei falsch, keinerlei Widerspruch.”
Since the work of Saul Kripke, philosophers have come to realize that the negation of metaphysically necessary truths need not involve a contradiction. For example, “Gold has the atomic number 79” or “This table could not have been made of ice.”
2. “Zweitens seien alle Versuche gescheitert, dieses Prinzip deduktiv zu beweisen.”
I disagree. I think it is obvious that something cannot come from nothing, from which it follows deductively that the universe has a cause its beginning.
3. “Drittens, sprechen sogar die empirischen Wissenschaften gegen die Wahrheit des Prinzips.”
This claim is based upon an indeterministic interpretation of quantum mechanics, for which there is no good evidence. The causal principle is always verified and never falsified.
Moreover, if things really can come into being uncaused, then why doesn’t just anything and everything come into being uncaused?
I also pointed out that on atheism there isn’t even the possibility of the universe before its beginning. But then it seems impossible that the universe could begin to exist.