Here’s my summary of the debate concerning my case:
Contingency Argument
Craig: The contingent universe has its ground in a metaphysically necessary being.
Beckermann: The contingent universe exists inexplicably.
Kalam Cosmological Argument
Craig: There is a personal Creator of the universe.
Beckermann: The universe may have popped into being without a cause.
Fine-Tuning Argument
Craig: There is Designer of the universe.
Beckermann: The universe just happens to be by chance fine-tuned for intelligent life.
Moral Argument
Craig: God is the ground of objective moral values and duties.
Beckermann: No alternative defended; as “biological machines” humans seem to have no objective values and duties.
Jesus’ Resurrection
Craig: God raised Jesus from the dead.
Beckermann: NT historians have erred concerning the facts of the empty tomb, post-mortem appearances, and origin of the disciples’ faith.
In his final rebuttal, Beckermann surprisingly denied that he was defending the above alternatives; but in that case he has no explanation of these facts and so no basis for thinking that naturalism is the better world view.
For his part, Beckermann defended the logical version of the problem of evil, which almost no one defends today. He presented a curious argument to the effect that God could justifiably permit evil only by treating people solely as means to some end, which is immoral. I gave a number of counter-examples to his claim. For example, contrary to his claim that there can be no justification for permitting a child to die a tortuous death, I pointed out that medical personnel performing triage or first responders to disasters often have to do just that--and are justified in doing so. Beckermann claimed that God, being omnipotent, could bring about the goods He desires without the suffering. But I pointed out that Beckermann was ignoring the critical distinction between what is logically possible for God and what is feasible for God. Beckermann failed to show that, given human free will, it is feasible for God to bring about a world having the goods God desires without the attendant evils.
Sydney Harbour
Harbour Bridge and Opera House
Harbour Bridge and Opera House - 2
St. Philips Anglican Church
Communion Cup from George III
Macquarie University
Great Hall Sydney University
Great Hall Audience
Peter Slezak
Dialogue on the Resurrection
Brisbane Outside Hall
Sydney Albert Quote
Sydney Krauss Quote
Melbourne Town Hall - 1
Melbourne Town Hall - 2
Melbourne Town Hall - 3
Pre-Debate Interview
Prayer Partners
Melbourne Dialogue
Sydney Opera House