bird silhouette

William Lane Craig

DOUBLE STANDARD

I find it interesting that Herr Beckermann applies a double standard when assessing my arguments and his own arguments. For example, he rejects such seemingly obvious truths as

Wenn das Universum zu existieren begann, hat das Universum eine transzendente Ursache.

Why? Because he thinks that this statement is neither true by definition, nor deductively provable, nor empirically provable. Never mind that I disagree with him about that. The more important point is that he does not apply the same standard to his own arguments.

For consider his own claims such as:

Gott kann die Güter, die Er will, herbeiführen, ohne jegliches Leid zuzulassen.

Es ist logisch unmöglich, dass Gott berechtigte Gründe hat, Leid in der Welt zuzulassen.

Es ist logisch unmöglich, eine rechtfertigung zu haben, ein Kind qualvoll sterben zu lassen.

None of these statements is true by definition, deductively provable, or empirically provable. By his own standards Beckermann should therefore reject these arguments.

So why does he accept his premises even though he rejects my premises? Simply because of their emotional appeal! That’s why he just heaps up examples of suffering like the holocaust, tsunamis, and dying children. Most atheist philosophers recognize that though such events are emotionally wrenching, they are not logically incompatible with God’s existence. But Herr Beckermann’s critical faculties have been overwhelmed by his emotions. We shouldn’t make the same mistake.