bird silhouette

William Lane Craig

FINE TUNING ANALOGIES

Suppose we were to ask everyone in the audience to think of a number and to write it down on a piece of paper. Suppose we were then to have them read out these numbers one after another. Any sequence of numbers which is read out will be equally improbable. But if the sequence turned out to be, for example, the sequence of the natural numbers 1, 2, 3, 4 . . . and so on, or the sequence of prime numbers, we would rightly conclude that this was not the result of chance but of design.

Why? Not merely because of the high improbability but because of its conformity to an independently given pattern. Similarly the initial conditions of the Big Bang are not merely highly improbable but also conform to the pattern of the conditions which are necessary for the existence of intelligent life.

***

We are rational to accept a highly improbable explanation only when there is no more probable explanation available. The existence of intelligent, interactive life is vastly more probable given God’s existence than it is on atheism.