William Lane Craig
NONTHEISTIC MORAL SYSTEMS
These theories typically just begin with the assumption that human beings have intrinsic moral worth. Given that assumption, one can work out a moral system with which the theist will largely agree. But on atheism that assumption seems questionable. Machines do not have intrinsic moral worth. But on Beckermanns view we are just biological machines—moist robots, as some naturalists have put it.
Moreover, it is especially difficult to find in the absence of any moral lawgiver a basis for moral duties. In the absence of God, who or what forbids us to do anything or obligates us to do anything? On atheism moral obligation and prohibition seem to be most plausibly subjective human illusions.