bird silhouette

William Lane Craig

PRINCIPLE OF SUFFICIENT REASON

The 19th century German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer rightly pointed out that the principle of sufficient reason can’t be dismissed like a taxi cab when you get to the universe. It is arbitrary and ad hoc to make the universe the exception to the principle.

There is nothing about the universe which makes it an exception to the principle of sufficient reason. It’s just big, and that’s not enough to say it can’t be explained. Beckermann is committing the taxicab fallacy, or else he’s assuming that the universe is all there is—which begs the question in favor of atheism!

***

Can we agree that it’s at least possible that the universe has an explanation? But then in some possible world there is a metaphysically necessary being that explains why the contingent universe exists. But if a metaphysically necessary being exists in any possible world, it exists in all of them. That’s the insight of the ontological argument. But then it follows that such a being exists in the actual world. So if it’s even possible that the universe has an explanation of its existence that explanation must exist.