William Lane Craig
BECKERMANN’S THREE CONTENTIONS
I. There are no good reasons to think that God exists.
Beckermann repeatedly says that the arguments for God are not “überzeugend.” But this is not a refutation of those arguments. Being überzeugend is a psychological state which is person-relative. I and many other contemporary philosophers find these arguments to be very überzeugend. It’s not enough in philosophical discussions to simply fold your arms and say that you are not überzeugt. What Beckermann needs to provide is reasons why these arguments are not überzeugend; and that he has failed to do.
II. Given the suffering in the world, either the world was created by an imperfect being or else the world has originated and evolved solely in accord with the laws of nature.
The problem with this dilemma is two-fold:
First, the naturalistic hypothesis that the world has originated and evolved solely in accord with the laws of nature cannot explain the origin and fine-tuning of those natural laws themselves. Nor can it explain why anything at all exists rather than nothing. Nor can it explain the existence of objective moral values and duties in the world. Nor can it explain events which transcend the power of natural laws to produce, like the resurrection of Jesus. Naturalism explains the suffering in the world, but it fails to account for all of the evidence.
Second, suffering does not rule out the existence of a vollkommenes Wesen. Beckermann falsely assumes that a vollkommenes Wesen has the ability to actualize just any logically possible state of affairs. But we have seen that that assumption is false. The Creator may be vollkommen but nevertheless unable to actualize a world of free creatures with this much good in it but without also this much suffering.
III. God cannot justifiably allow a child to suffer and die.
Appealing to the suffering of children has great emotional force. But Beckermann’s argument for this claim is philosophically defective, as even most atheist philosophers recognize. Medical personnel and first responders allow children to suffer and die without violating Kant’s imperative because they have morally sufficient reasons for doing so. In the same way, God can have morally sufficient reasons for permitting such suffering in this life. Indeed, on the Christian view God never treats anyone solely as a means to an end but, in accord with Kant’s Imperative, desires and works to achieve their free and eternal salvation.