William Lane Craig
RESPONSE TO KURT FLASCH
Kurt Flasch, Warum ich kein Christ bin (Munchen: C. H. Beck, 2013)
Flasch shows no acquaintance with contemporary historical-critical studies of Jesus’ resurrection. He simply repeats the tired, old skeptical line from bygone generations.
What is remarkable is that despite his skepticism Flasch actually agrees with two of the three facts I cited in support of Jesus’s resurrection. The only one he disputes is the women’s discovery of the empty tomb. So Flasch still owes us explanations for the postmortem appearances of Jesus and the origin of the disciples’ belief in his resurrection, explanations which he does not even try to give.
When it comes to the fact of the empty tomb, Flasch bases his skepticism on the differences between the Gospel accounts. He doesn’t seem to appreciate that these differences are in the secondary details of the accounts and that such differences are expected by historical-critical scholars. For example, survivors of the Titanic disagreed with one another whether the ship broke in two before it sank; yet no one would deny the sinking of the Titanic on the basis of this contradiction. So why does Flasch mention these contradictions? He says:
“Wenn Zeugen sich widersprechen, beweisst das Historikern nicht, dass nichts passiert ist. Widersprüche der genannten Art sind allerdings schwer vereinbar mit der Annahme, der Heilige Geist selbst habe alle Sätze der Bibel wörtlich diktiert. Nur deshalb habe ich sie aufgelistet.”
This is incredible! Never mind that no theologian thinks that the Holy Spirit dictated the Bible! The more important point is that Flasch has completely lost his way historically. The historical question is whether we can get behind the differences to the historical core of the narratives. Flasch gives no reason for thinking that we cannot. Indeed, the majority of historical scholars think that we can.
As the Austrian scholar Jacob Kremer points out, “by far most exegetes hold firmly to the reliability of the biblical statements concerning the empty tomb,” on the basis of evidence such as the following:
1. The discovery of the empty tomb is narrated in early, independent sources.
2. The reliability of the account of Jesus’ burial supports the historicity of the empty tomb.
3. The tomb was most likely discovered empty by women.
4. The earliest Jewish polemic itself presupposes the empty tomb.
Flasch does not even try to discuss such matters.
So what does Flasch think happened to the body of Jesus? Incredibly, he says, “Jesus könnte scheintot sein oder der tote Jesus lag in einem anderen Grab.” This is just embarrassing. I cannot emphasize too strongly that no historical scholar today would defend the apparent death theory or the wrong tomb hypothesis.
The bottom line is that Herr Beckermann has been misled by an unreliable guide in matters concerning the historical Jesus.
***
Kurt Flasch, Warum ich kein Christ bin (Munchen: C. H. Beck, 2013)
Auferstehung
Resurrection of Jeus is “die zentrale Frage” for someone who is no longer a Christian 120
“Jesus koennte scheintot sein oder der tote Jesus lag in einem anderen Grab.” 121
Paul never calls Jesus ‘God’ 121
Gospel contradictions; all appearances like Paul’s visionary experience; spiritual body
In John Jesus goes through doors like a ghost 123
Mk 16.8 implies no one in Jerusalem except the women knew about the empty tomb during the first few years 124
If I were the police commissioner I couldn’t have been able to tell on the basis of these testimonies What happened to the body of the prominent man 126
“Wichtig ist, was allen Zeugen gemeinsam ist: Nach der Katastrophe der Hinrichtung begann die Jesusbewegung neu. Die Erscheinungen bildeten fuer die Beteiligten den Wendepunkt zu neuem Leben.” 127
“Wenn Zeugen sich widersprechen, beweisst das Historikern nicht, dass nichts passiert ist. Widersprueche der genannten Art sind allerdings schwer vereinbar mit der Annahme, der Heilige Geist selbst habe alle Saetze der Bibel woertlich diktiert. Nur deshalb habe ich sie aufgelistet.” 128
“Die historisch-kritische Betrachtung. . . erwartet bei geschichtlichen Gegenstaenden Entwicklungen.” 128
“Wir koennen nicht zurueckgreifen hinter die Verschiedenheit der Erzaehlungen.” 129