bird silhouette

William Lane Craig

RESURRECTION

Beckermann asks, Has anyone written a book about how many Fachleute take a particular position on Jesus’ resurrection?

In fact, such a study has been done, and it is mentioned in the very Wikipedia article that Herr Beckermann cites! Gary Habermas has surveyed 3,500 publications on Jesus’ resurrection from 1975 to the present in English, French, and German. His study shows that 75% of scholars accept the historicity of the empty tomb, and even greater percentages accept the historicity of post-mortem appearances and of the disciples’ coming to believe in Jesus’ resurrection.

Beckermann mentions a recent Sammelband which collects articles pro and con on various questions, including Jesus’ resurrection. But who is the author of the negative article? A prominent New Testament historian? No! Michael Martin, a philosopher who has no expertise in this area! Worse, the late Prof. Martin was one of the old guard atheist philosophers from the prior generation, before the renaissance of Christian philosophy which I have described. He hardly represents current scholarship on the historical Jesus.

Even worse is Beckermann’s appeal to Wikipedia, which advertises itself as “the free encyclopedia which anyone can edit,” as his source of information. I won’t say anything more about this, except to note that the article also lists 8 lines of evidence which have convinced most scholars of the historicity of the empty tomb, and it doesn’t even include the most important.

The bottom line is that Beckermann hasn’t provided any good reason for rejecting the facts accepted by the majority of experts that undergird the resurrection of Jesus.